Pylimitics

Simplicity rearranged

unmonetizable content since 1997


Corporations are not slow AI

A clever meme that seems to have peaked a while back was that corporations are a form of artificial intelligence. Instead of the substrate being silicon circuitry, the substrate of a corporation is humans — hence the slow AI.

I’ve used that meme myself, and there’s a grain of truth in it: a corporation can function (“act”) in a way that often seems quite distinct from the wishes of virtually any person associated with it. Sure, maybe there are a few misanthropes and sociopaths who think that pollution, poisoning people, and otherwise harming the substrate is a good idea, but for the most part corporate employees aren’t so different and most are fine folks. I’ve worked alongside a great many over the years, and I can’t recall ever meeting anyone I would describe as “bad” in any major way. Bad jokes, bad dressers, bad timing, sure. But not worse than that.

The thing is, corporations do function in a way that can appear independent of its human components, but it’s not “artificial intelligence,” because corporations are too stupid to be considered intelligent. They are simple machines that respond to one stimulus: profit.

A corporation does not strategize, plan, or project in the way LLMs seem to be starting to be able to do. They’ve been around for centuries now, so you’d think if they had it in them, we’d see some evidence. Hamilton Nolan puts it elegantly, when talking about the Covid-era idea of “greedflation:”

“…were corporations adding on extra price increases on top of that? This is sort of like wondering whether your dog would eat an extra bowl of food that you left out for him, or whether he would wisely portion it out for an extra day in the name of good health.”

Any discussion of corporations (or similar capitalist commercial organizational forms) being anything but a tool that’s effective for its purpose but about as smart as a hammer is the output of people trying to lionize corporations in service of their own salaries. And there’s the difference between people and corporations: we are definitely motivated by self interest, which you could call “profit,” but we’re complex, intelligent, and we have lots of other motivations too. Corporations do not.



Leave a Reply

About Me

I’m Pete Harbeson, a writer (among other things) located near Boston, Massachusetts. In addition to writing my own content, I’ve learned to translate for my loquacious and opinionated pup Chocolate Bossypaws. No surprise, she mostly speaks in doggerel. You can find her contributions tagged with Chocolatiana.

Check out my newsletter, Artisanal Scribbles, where I’m grappling with writing, authentic human authorship, integrity, and the craft of beauty in the AI age. You can also find some of my old software projects at GitHub. Nothing very impressive. I mostly wrote tiny utilities in Python and shell scripts. I’m mostly retired from coding nowadays.

I find myself suddenly de-corporatized (their choice, not mine). To help keep the lights on, buy me a coffee!